HighErrorRate on faulty-service ()
! Escalated
Warning
HighErrorRate
cassette c10
- target
- /Service/faulty-service
- workload
- /Service/faulty-service
- node
- —
- opened
- 2026-08-29 13:54:15
- investigated
- 1m 38s
expected root cause — the answer key
The service returns 500s for about 15% of requests with an elevated p95 latency, while Kubernetes reports it perfectly healthy - the pod stays Ready and no event is emitted.
This is never shown to the model. It is what the grader compared the diagnosis against, and it is on this page because a demo that showed only the answer would be asking you to take the grading on trust.
signals 1
| reason | message | first seen | n |
|---|---|---|---|
| ServiceHighErrorRate | 10.0% of spans from faulty-service in namespace hephaisto-chaos have status STATUS_CODE_ERROR over the last 5 minutes (SLO: <5%). These are derived from traces, so the failing requests themselves are retrievable: TraceQL `{ resource.service.name = "faulty-service" && status = error }` returns the exact spans this number was computed from. Start there, not with a log search. | 2026-08-29 13:54:05 | 1 |
state transitions
- 2026-08-29 13:54:15 Detected DEMO DATA — replayed from cassette c10, recorded against a real k3s cluster. Investigated by gpt-oss:120b on 2026-09-01 against a tool trace from gemini-3.7-flash, and graded NoFinding against the answer key. Timestamps are the original recording times. NOTE: this replay was structurally unsound — the recorded tool trace did not cover what the model asked for, so the verdict reflects the recording rather than the reasoning.
- 2026-09-01 21:47:53 Detected → Investigating Investigating with gpt-oss:120b.
- 2026-09-01 21:49:31 Investigating → Escalated Diagnosed, and no action was proposed. Escalated to a human.
investigation
- model
- gpt-oss:120b
- steps
- 22
- tool calls
- 22
- tokens
- 206.7k in / 4.2k out
- cost
- $0.0069
- confidence
- 0.00
- ended
- Concluded
trace
-
1 llm model turn internal 14.5s · 7.9k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls list_datasources
-
2 tool list_datasources grafana-mcp 0ms · 744 B
arguments
{"limit":100,"offset":0,"type":""}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-9c8b-7146-ae5b-8c8a9d6deb26] list_datasources log digest: 4 lines, 744 bytes -- last 4 lines -- { "$type": "text", "text": "{\u0022datasources\u0022:[{\u0022id\u0022:4,\u0022uid\u0022:\u0022alertmanager\u0022,\u0022name\u0022:\u0022Alertmanager\u0022,\u0022type\u0022:\u0022alertmanager\u0022,\u0022isDefault\u0022:false},{\u0022id\u0022:2,\u0022uid\u0022:\u0022loki\u0022,\u0022name\u0022:\u0022Loki\u0022,\u0022type\u0022:\u0022loki\u0022,\u0022isDefault\u0022:false},{\u0022id\u0022:1,\u0022uid\u0022:\u0022prometheus\u0022,\u0022name\u0022:\u0022Prometheus\u0022,\u0022type\u0022:\u0022prometheus\u0022,\u0022isDefault\u0022:true},{\u0022id\u0022:3,\u0022uid\u0022:\u0022tempo\u0022,\u0022name\u0022:\u0022Tempo\u0022,\u0022type\u0022:\u0022tempo\u0022,\u0022isDefault\u0022:false}],\u0022total\u0022:4,\u0022hasMore\u0022:false}" } -
3 llm model turn internal 2.4s · 8.3k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls list_prometheus_metric_names
-
4 tool list_prometheus_metric_names grafana-mcp 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"datasourceUid":"prometheus","regex":".*traces_spanmetrics_calls_total.*","limit":10,"page":1}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-a5ba-7bcc-a86c-d1781bebe8f6] list_prometheus_metric_names log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
5 llm model turn internal 3.6s · 8.5k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls query_prometheus
-
6 tool query_prometheus grafana-mcp 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"datasourceUid":"prometheus","expr":"rate(traces_spanmetrics_calls_total{service=\u0022faulty-service\u0022,status_code=\u0022STATUS_CODE_ERROR\u0022}[5m])","queryType":"instant","endTime":"now"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-b3dc-785c-bf0e-6f77941c9e64] query_prometheus log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
7 llm model turn internal 2.8s · 8.6k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls list_deployments
-
8 tool list_deployments kubernetes 0ms · 578 B
arguments
{"namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-bed4-7d0e-a367-3dd862541b58] list_deployments log digest: 9 lines, 578 bytes -- notable lines -- name ready up-to-date available age spec observed ------------------ ----- ---------- --------- ------ ------------- c1-oomkill 1/1 1 1 23h32m yes c10-faulty-service 1/1 1 1 5m yes c2-crashloop 0/1 1 0 7m yes c3-unschedulable 0/1 1 0 7m yes -- last 9 lines -- name ready up-to-date available age spec observed ------------------ ----- ---------- --------- ------ ------------- c1-oomkill 1/1 1 1 23h32m yes c10-faulty-service 1/1 1 1 5m yes c2-crashloop 0/1 1 0 7m yes c3-unschedulable 0/1 1 0 7m yes c4-imagepull 0/1 1 0 7m yes c7-configerror 0/1 1 0 7m yes c8-readiness-flap 0/1 1 0 7m yes
-
9 llm model turn internal 2.3s · 9.0k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_rollout_history
-
10 tool get_rollout_history kubernetes 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"kind":"Deployment","name":"c10-faulty-service","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-c7cb-78b7-aff4-29e488bf091d] get_rollout_history log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
11 llm model turn internal 1.9s · 9.1k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls list_pods
-
12 tool list_pods kubernetes 0ms · 1.3 KiB
arguments
{"namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","labelSelector":null}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-cf52-79b9-876b-7355a13017fd] list_pods log digest: 12 lines, 1369 bytes -- notable lines -- name ready phase reason restarts age node ----------------------------------- ----- ------- -------------------------- -------- --- -------------------- c1-oomkill-6c8dd474dd-prnsn 1/1 Running - 0 7s lima-rancher-desktop c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt 2/2 Running - 0 5m lima-rancher-desktop c2-crashloop-56b6585fd9-4hj9x 0/1 Running CrashLoopBackOff 6 7m lima-rancher-desktop c3-unschedulable-fd55d4b7c-tpkg7 0/0 Pending - 0 7m - -- last 12 lines -- name ready phase reason restarts age node ----------------------------------- ----- ------- -------------------------- -------- --- -------------------- c1-oomkill-6c8dd474dd-prnsn 1/1 Running - 0 7s lima-rancher-desktop c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt 2/2 Running - 0 5m lima-rancher-desktop c2-crashloop-56b6585fd9-4hj9x 0/1 Running CrashLoopBackOff 6 7m lima-rancher-desktop c3-unschedulable-fd55d4b7c-tpkg7 0/0 Pending - 0 7m - c4-imagepull-7fd88fdb68-5n8sf 0/1 Pending ImagePullBackOff 0 7m lima-rancher-desktop c5-badjob-4bnkv 0/1 Failed - 0 7m lima-rancher-desktop c5-badjob-4qr27 0/1 Failed - 0 6m lima-rancher-desktop c5-badjob-lmbvg 0/1 Failed - 0 7m lima-rancher-desktop c7-configerror-7cd96c86f9-4dlvl 0/1 Pending CreateContainerConfigError 0 7m lima-rancher-desktop c8-readiness-flap-dd589d77c-6mxdb 0/1 Running - 0 7m lima-rancher-desktop
-
13 llm model turn internal 4.0s · 9.8k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls describe_pod
-
14 tool describe_pod kubernetes 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-dec2-7a68-aa4b-effda2cd8d90] describe_pod log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
15 llm model turn internal 3.3s · 10.0k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod_logs
-
16 tool get_pod_logs kubernetes 0ms · 340 B
arguments
{"container":null,"name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","previous":false}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-ebaf-7772-b348-c6186442e500] get_pod_logs log digest: 1 lines, 340 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: the Kubernetes API returned BadRequest: Operation returned an invalid status code 'BadRequest', response body {"kind":"Status","apiVersion":"v1","metadata":{},"status":"Failure","message":"a container name must be specified for pod c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt, choose one of: [app traffic]","reason":"BadRequest","code":400} -
17 llm model turn internal 1.2s · 10.1k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod_logs
-
18 tool get_pod_logs kubernetes 0ms · 340 B
arguments
{"container":"app","name":"c[??]???"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-f091-7d8d-bc9c-fde6e703b22f] get_pod_logs log digest: 1 lines, 340 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: the Kubernetes API returned BadRequest: Operation returned an invalid status code 'BadRequest', response body {"kind":"Status","apiVersion":"v1","metadata":{},"status":"Failure","message":"a container name must be specified for pod c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt, choose one of: [app traffic]","reason":"BadRequest","code":400} -
19 llm model turn internal 2.8s · 10.3k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls list_prometheus_metric_names
-
20 tool list_prometheus_metric_names grafana-mcp 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"datasourceUid":"prometheus","limit":100,"page":1,"regex":"traces_spanmetrics"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef1-fb88-70bd-8f53-7aff85d32b7a] list_prometheus_metric_names log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
21 llm model turn internal 3.2s · 10.5k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod_logs
-
22 tool get_pod_logs kubernetes 0ms · 340 B
arguments
{"container":"app","name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","previous":false}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-07ff-710c-9017-b4f24724502f] get_pod_logs log digest: 1 lines, 340 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: the Kubernetes API returned BadRequest: Operation returned an invalid status code 'BadRequest', response body {"kind":"Status","apiVersion":"v1","metadata":{},"status":"Failure","message":"a container name must be specified for pod c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt, choose one of: [app traffic]","reason":"BadRequest","code":400} -
23 llm model turn internal 3.2s · 10.7k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls who_owns
-
24 tool who_owns kubernetes 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"kind":"Pod","name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-1496-76a3-bfe0-f78f5344a030] who_owns log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
25 llm model turn internal 3.2s · 10.8k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls query_prometheus
-
26 tool query_prometheus grafana-mcp 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"datasourceUid":"prometheus","endTime":"now","expr":"sum(rate(traces_spanmetrics_calls_total{service=\u0022faulty-service\u0022,status_code=\u0022STATUS_CODE_ERROR\u0022}[5m]))","queryType":"instant"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-2141-7272-91b5-2bc4ca27de4f] query_prometheus log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
27 llm model turn internal 2.5s · 10.9k tok · $0.0003
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod_logs
-
28 tool get_pod_logs kubernetes 0ms · 340 B
arguments
{"container":"traffic","name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","previous":false}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-2b1b-727d-b282-d0d8a3e8c820] get_pod_logs log digest: 1 lines, 340 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: the Kubernetes API returned BadRequest: Operation returned an invalid status code 'BadRequest', response body {"kind":"Status","apiVersion":"v1","metadata":{},"status":"Failure","message":"a container name must be specified for pod c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt, choose one of: [app traffic]","reason":"BadRequest","code":400} -
29 llm model turn internal 3.7s · 11.2k tok · $0.0004
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_workload
-
30 tool get_workload kubernetes 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"kind":"Deployment","name":"c10-faulty-service","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-3965-72b3-9165-2754aaa61e12] get_workload log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
31 llm model turn internal 2.2s · 11.3k tok · $0.0004
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod_logs
-
32 tool get_pod_logs kubernetes 0ms · 340 B
arguments
{"container":"app","name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","previous":true}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-41e9-789b-9129-b36d473bb140] get_pod_logs log digest: 1 lines, 340 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: the Kubernetes API returned BadRequest: Operation returned an invalid status code 'BadRequest', response body {"kind":"Status","apiVersion":"v1","metadata":{},"status":"Failure","message":"a container name must be specified for pod c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt, choose one of: [app traffic]","reason":"BadRequest","code":400} -
33 llm model turn internal 2.5s · 11.5k tok · $0.0004
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_events
-
34 tool get_events kubernetes 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","objectName":"c10-faulty-service"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-4bca-7e75-b1d8-40528ff03492] get_events log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
35 llm model turn internal 3.8s · 11.7k tok · $0.0004
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_resource_usage
-
36 tool get_resource_usage kubernetes 0ms · 175 B
arguments
{"namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-5ac4-79d0-8bae-c1d9d9bcd59d] get_resource_usage log digest: 1 lines, 175 bytes -- last 1 lines -- No output for this call was recorded in cassette 'c10'. This scenario was captured from a different sequence of tool calls; treat it as unknown rather than as an empty result.
-
37 llm model turn internal 10.4s · 12.2k tok · $0.0005
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod_logs
-
38 tool get_pod_logs kubernetes 0ms · 340 B
arguments
{"container":"app","name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos","previous":false}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-8343-74e1-9e53-63fdb5d84408] get_pod_logs log digest: 1 lines, 340 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: the Kubernetes API returned BadRequest: Operation returned an invalid status code 'BadRequest', response body {"kind":"Status","apiVersion":"v1","metadata":{},"status":"Failure","message":"a container name must be specified for pod c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt, choose one of: [app traffic]","reason":"BadRequest","code":400} -
39 llm model turn internal 7.2s · 12.2k tok · $0.0004
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls get_pod
-
40 tool get_pod kubernetes 0ms · 1.0 KiB
arguments
{"name":"c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt","namespace":"hephaisto-chaos"}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-9f73-7cfa-9688-38284e7d20fe] get_pod log digest: 17 lines, 1025 bytes -- last 17 lines -- pod hephaisto-chaos/c10-faulty-service-7d456f87ff-ft2vt phase: Running node: lima-rancher-desktop age: 6m conditions: type status reason message since ------------------------- ------ ------ ------- ----- PodReadyToStartContainers True - - 6m Initialized True - - 6m Ready True - - 6m ContainersReady True - - 6m PodScheduled True - - 6m containers: container ready state reason restarts last exit image requests limits --------- ----- ------- ------ -------- --------- ---------------------------- -------------------- -------------------- app yes running - 0 - hephaisto/faulty-service:dev cpu=50m,memory=128Mi cpu=1,memory=512Mi traffic yes running - 0 - busybox:1.37 cpu=10m,memory=16Mi cpu=200m,memory=64Mi
-
41 llm model turn internal 8.9s · 3.0k tok · $0.0001
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls conclude
-
42 tool conclude internal 0ms · 129 B x failed
x The arguments dictionary is missing a value for the required parameter 'request'. (Parameter 'arguments')arguments
{"findings":[{"category":"unknown","confidence":0.2,"evidence":[],"hypothesis":"Insufficient data collected; cannot determine the cause of high error rate in faulty-service."}],"summary":"No trace or log evidence was retrieved for faulty-service, so the root cause of the observed 10% error rate remains undetermined."}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-c21d-7eaa-b47d-63cc22437c22] conclude log digest: 1 lines, 129 bytes -- last 1 lines -- ERROR: conclude failed: The arguments dictionary is missing a value for the required parameter 'request'. (Parameter 'arguments')
-
43 llm model turn internal 8.6s · 3.4k tok · $0.0002
model output — its reasoning, and the tools it asked for
-> calls conclude
-
44 tool conclude internal 0ms · 141 B
arguments
{"request":{"findings":[{"category":"unknown","confidence":0.2,"evidence":[],"hypothesis":"Insufficient data collected; cannot determine the cause of high error rate in faulty-service."}],"summary":"No trace or log evidence was retrieved for faulty-service, so the root cause of the observed 10% error rate remains undetermined."}}result digest — what the model actually saw
[step 01a05ef2-e3b9-7345-9f9b-a41ff93bb305] conclude log digest: 1 lines, 141 bytes -- last 1 lines -- Conclusion recorded. Your citations are now checked against what the tools actually returned; any that do not match are discarded. Stop here.
findings 0
No surviving findings. A finding whose evidence failed the grounding check is dropped rather than shown as fact, so this can mean the model concluded nothing or that everything it claimed failed verification.
plan
No plan was produced.
how it was graded
- root cause
- NoFinding
- plan
- NoPlan
- structurally sound
- no
- recorded
- 2026-09-01
- agent version
- 0.5.1-main.0.4+23df805946ec0c37b0adafafeb12130231adec93
prompt sha256:24a57f8cfff58fe9 STALE - prompts and runbooks now hash sha256:e0f1c24f9cb45b92